ARCO 57-5376 Outboard Starter Motor – Johnson / Evinrude OMC
Free returns on all eligible orders
You have 30 days to request a return. All sale items are final sale.
ARCO 57-5376 Outboard Starter Motor
Get your Johnson or Evinrude outboard cranking reliably again with this direct-fit replacement starter from ARCO Marine. Built to OEM specifications, the 57-5376 is a drop-in solution for a wide range of OMC outboards — no modifications required. Whether you’re dealing with a slow crank, a no-start, or a starter that’s finally given out, this is the part that gets you back on the water.
Compatible Applications
- Johnson / Evinrude OMC outboards (see OEM part number cross-reference below)
Replaces OEM Part Numbers
- OMC 386591
- OMC 392133
- OMC 585061
- OMC 586278
- OMC 385401
- OMC 174942
- OMC 175019
Drive Gear: 11-tooth
Parts Desk Insights
This starter is the right call when your OMC outboard turns over slowly, clicks but won’t crank, or fails to start entirely. Best suited for boaters who want a reliable, American-engineered replacement that installs without hassle. Before replacing the starter, it’s worth confirming the solenoid is functioning — pair this with the ARCO OMC Solenoid (57-SW268) or the OMC Starter Solenoid if needed. For extended starter life, the ARCO Starter Motor Brush Kit (57-BK900) is a smart addition to any service kit.
Shipping information
In-stock and OEM parts: ship same or next business day.
Locally warehoused items: ship within 1-3 business days.
Special-order items: timeline confirmed after order.
Returns & warranty
Returns & Satisfaction Guarantee
We stand firmly behind the quality of every product we sell. Your confidence matters to us — and we back it with a straightforward 30-Day Satisfaction Guarantee.
If you are not fully satisfied, you may request a return within 30 days of delivery. All returns must receive pre-approval prior to being sent back. Unauthorized returns will not be accepted.
To qualify for a return:
Item must be in new, unused condition
Product must be in its original packaging
All parts, components, hardware, manuals, and accessories must be included
Packaging must be undamaged and suitable for resale
Important:
Electronics are strictly inspected. No returns on open-box electronics. Exceptions may apply only with prior written approval. Any electronic unit that has been installed, powered, activated, or altered may not be eligible for return.
We are serious about product integrity — and equally serious about taking care of our customers. If there is ever a product issue, contact us immediately so we can make it right.
For return authorization, please contact our support team before shipping anything back.